Arizona’s Immigration Law Spurs Copycat Legislation

Arizona’s Immigration Law Spurs Copycat Legislation

Story tools


A A AResize


Share and Email


Arizona’s new get-tough immigration law has emboldened other state capitols to follow suit.

Legislators in at least 10 states— Utah, Oklahoma, Colorado, Ohio, Missouri, Georgia, South Carolina, Mississippi, Texas, and Maryland— have called for laws that would mirror Arizona’s Senate Bill 1070, according to the Progressive States Network and reporting by New America Media.

First out of the gate to actually introduce a bill was South Carolina.

Along with 20 co-sponsors, Rep. Eric Bedingfield, a Republican, introduced a bill April 29 that, like Arizona’s, requires law enforcement officials to check individuals’ immigration status.

Some of the language in the South Carolina bill, which was posted on the legislature’s website, is virtually identical to the most controversial portion of the Arizona measure signed into law by Gov. Jan Brewer on April 23.

The South Carolina bill reads: “When reasonable suspicion exists that the person is an alien who is unlawfully present in the United States, a reasonable attempt must be made, when practicable, to determine the immigration status of the person.”

Civil rights advocates, like the Rev. Al Sharpton, blasted the same phrasing in the Arizona law as opening the door to ethnic profiling of Latinos and anyone else appearing foreign-born. Kevin R. Johnson, dean of the University of California, Davis School of Law, agrees the language is “very open-ended” and that some of the civil rights concerns over the Arizona law are warranted. But, he argues, successful legal challenges will likely focus on the far more clear-cut case that such laws usurp the federal government’s constitutionally granted supremacy over immigration.

Even so, state capitals, county seats and city halls insist on trying to legislate immigration controls.

In 2007, for example, Oklahoma passed a hard-line immigration law that, while not as tough as Arizona’s, imposed a set of controls on employers and made it a felony to harbor, shelter or transport undocumented immigrants.

This year, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Tenth Circuit struck down a section of the Oklahoma law pertaining to penalties on employers. The court said the Oklahoma measure was pre-empted in that area by federal law.

But that didn’t frighten Oklahoma legislators away from the immigration issue. They are now cobbling together proposals that would outdo even Arizona. Republican Rep. Randy Terrill has said a bill he’s authoring may go one step further and provide for the seizure and forfeiture of property of those caught in immigration violations. Latino communities in Oklahoma, who lived through panic and an exodus in the wake of the 2007 law, are bracing for a new crackdown, says Patricia Fennel, executive director of the Tulsa-based Latino Community Development Agency.

“With the legislature we have now, if that [new] legislation was introduced tomorrow, I think it would pass easily,” says Fennel.

The controversial Arizona law may be emboldening immigration hardliners.

But as Oklahoma’s own experience shows, states’ efforts to curb illegal immigration—and criminalize it— pre-date Arizona’s new bill.

But Arizona’s action seems to have spread the idea that state-level immigration laws can get tougher. Mississippi passed a bill in 2008 that made it a felony for an undocumented immigrant to solicit or accept work in the state. Now, Mississippi legislators are calling for the state to adopt Arizona’s tougher approach, according to Bill Chandler, executive director of the Mississippi Immigrant Rights Alliance. The handful of state legislators known for their frequent “ranting and raving” about illegal immigration “ramped it up since Arizona,” adds Chandler.

In Missouri, a broad bill to crack down on illegal immigration was being considered in the legislature as Arizona debated and passed its law. The Missouri bill, the subject of hearings last week, would make it a felony to knowingly transport or harbor an undocumented immigrant. But now the bill’s sponsor, Republican Rep. Mark Parkinson, says he will go further and introduce legislation similar to Arizona’s next year.

Utah is another state that has recently taken a hard tack on immigration. A Utah law, which went into effect last year, sought to prevent state employers from hiring undocumented immigrants and also made it illegal to harbor them. At the same time, undocumented immigrants are allowed in-state tuition in Utah schools, and the influential Mormon Church allows undocumented immigrants to be bishops.

Now, Republican Rep. Stephen Sandstrom says he’s drafting a bill modeled on Arizona’s. "With Arizona making the first step in this direction, Utah needs to pass a similar law or we will see a huge influx of illegals,” he was quoted as saying in The Salt Lake Tribune.

Despite the rash of calls for copycat legislation, it is likely an attitude of caution will prevail in many places, says Suman Raghunathan, who tracks immigration policy for the New York-based Progressive States Network, which works with progressive state legislators nationwide.

In Texas, for example, some legislators have called for a local version of the Arizona law. But Gov. Rick Perry, a conservative Republican, has cautioned against doing that. So has the business community.

States aren’t the only jurisdictions trying to craft their own immigration laws. Last year, Farmers Branch, a suburb of Dallas, Texas, passed an ordinance seeking to bar landlords from renting apartments to undocumented immigrants. That ordinance was struck down by the federal courts, as was a similar one passed a few years ago in Hazelton, Penn.

However, states and localities will continue taking matters into their own hands until Congress enacts federal immigration reform. Congressional action seems at least possible this year after Senate Democrats’ release of an immigration reform blueprint last week.

Immigrant advocates like to point out that both the backers and detractors of Arizona-style laws agree that the nation’s immigration system is broken. The question is when the U.S. Congress and White House will summon the resolve fix it.

“The crisis in Arizona today only shows what happens when the federal government fails to do its job,” says Ali Noorani, executive director of the National Immigration Forum.




Posted Dec 9 2010


Reyes Kellner

Posted Dec 13 2010

Yeah i did look at it, that house washing looks great. That pressure washing company in Knoville did a really good job.

kvepalai vyrams

Posted Jan 8 2011

Nice blog here! Also your site loads up fast! What host are you using? Can I get your affiliate link to your host? I wish my website loaded up as quickly as yours lol

vyriski kvepalai

Posted Jan 8 2011

Simply want to say your article is as astounding. The clarity in your post is simply excellent and i can assume you are an expert on this subject. Fine with your permission allow me to grab your feed to keep updated with forthcoming post. Thanks a million and please continue the enjoyable work.

The rosetta stone

Posted Jan 26 2011

I'll gear this review to 2 types of people: current Zune owners who are considering an upgrade, and people trying to decide between a Zune and an iPod. (There are other players worth considering out there, like the Sony Walkman X, but I hope this gives you enough info to make an informed decision of the Zune vs players other than the iPod line as well.)

girls peeing

Posted Feb 5 2011

Quite helpful write-up. I simply stumbled upon your internet site and wanted to say that I’ve quite favored learning your blog posts. Any signifies I’ll be subscribing inside your feed and I hope you publish after additional soon.

Andrew A. Sailer

Posted Feb 6 2011

Is there much best Canon Powershot digital (duh) camera? I want to buy for mostly "casual" shots (christmas, birthdays, family reunions... that form of stuff). And occasionally a lot of cool artistic photos. I'm told which a 6-7 mm lens could be the best... Other than in which, what else is excellent???

escort istanbul

Posted Feb 10 2011

Eğer istanbulda bir escort bayan arıyorsanız bizden daha kalitelisini bulamazsınız. Eğlence ve seks de limiti olmayan kızlarımıza sadece bir tık uzaktasınız.

zero friction marketing

Posted Feb 11 2011

You made a number of fine points there. I did a search on the subject matter and found most persons will agree with your blog.

zero friction marketing

Posted Feb 11 2011

You completed several nice points there. I did a search on the subject and found mainly people will go along with with your blog.

Theodore Dennie

Posted Feb 14 2011

It was beyond than that, besides commercial property they also do Knoxville residential pressure washing too.

tani hosting stron www

Posted Feb 15 2011

Youre so cool! I dont suppose Ive read anything like this before. So nice to find somebody with some original thoughts on this subject. realy thank you for starting this up. this website is something that is needed on the web, someone with a little originality. useful job for bringing something new to the internet!

najlepszy seo hosting

Posted Feb 22 2011

It's hard to find knowledgeable people on this topic, but you sound like you know what you're talking about! Thanks

najlepszy hosting seo

Posted Mar 8 2011

This really answered my problem, thank you!

tani seo hosting

Posted Mar 10 2011

you have a great blog here! would you like to make some invite posts on my blog?

applying makeup

Posted Mar 12 2011

Hey, this is a super blog. I'm always searching for blogs similar to this. Maintain the good job!

Issac Maez

Posted Mar 12 2011

I must express my admiration for your kindness in support of those people who actually need help with this particular niche. Your personal commitment to getting the message up and down has been surprisingly significant and has in most cases encouraged folks much like me to get to their targets. Your amazing important help can mean so much to me and somewhat more to my mates. Warm regards; from each one of us.

pinkish glow

Posted Mar 12 2011

Hey, this can be a nice website. I'm invariably on the lookout for blogs similar to this. Continue the great job!

san diego real estate investments

Posted Mar 14 2011

Thanks for this post, I am a big big fan of this website would like to proceed updated.

zero friction marketing

Posted Mar 17 2011

I just now wanted to tell you how much I actually appreciate everything you've contributed to help improve lives of folks in this theme. Through your articles, I've really gone through just an inexperienced to a skilled in the area. It truly is truly a tribute to your efforts. Thanks

fettabsaugung forum

Posted Mar 15 2012

Dennoch birgt ein operativer Eingriff rund um die Uhr Risiken, über die der behandelnde Mediziner ausführlich ins Vertrauen ziehen sollte.

Disclaimer: Comments do not necessarily reflect the views of New America Media. NAM reserves the right to edit or delete comments. Once published, comments are visible to search engines and will remain in their archives. If you do not want your identity connected to comments on this site, please refrain from commenting or use a handle or alias instead of your real name.