Lessons in Freedom From the CIA

Lessons in Freedom From the CIA

Story tools

Comments

A A AResize

Print

Share and Email

 
Three weeks ago, The Arab American News published a story written by The Associated Press about the CIA and the NYPD cooperating in a massive spying operation on the entire Muslim community in the New York/New Jersey area.

The following week, we published an article detailing the CIA's denial of that activity.

As we went to press last week, Thursday, September 8, 2011, we received an email from the advertising agency which handles the CIA's account. "The government agency for the CIA has just contacted us and wants us to remove the banners from your website for undisclosed reasons," the agency said in its email. A representative from the advertising agency haunted our advertising director all afternoon, repeatedly asking to immediately remove the four ads that the agency just ordered eight days ago. Another email three hours later from the same agency: "Sorry to keep bothering you but the client is giving me a headache." The CIA has canceled all advertising in The Arab American News.

This is not the first time that a government agency has canceled advertising with our paper because of our editorial position. A few years ago, after the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq, Titan Corporation placed recruitment ads for bilingual translators to assist government agencies working in Iraq, including the U.S. armed forces. The ads ran in this paper on a weekly basis in both the Arabic and English sections. Later Titan's officials called us and, citing our editorial position on opposing the war in Iraq, canceled all ads and told us that their company would not place any future ads in this paper. (The Arab American News took a very strong and vocal position opposing the U.S.-led invasion of Iraq.)

This newspaper was instrumental in inviting the CIA into the community, introducing its employees to community leaders and helping to forge good relations between the force and local organizations. The CIA has sponsored many events in the community and generally been welcomed with open arms.

But the evidence shows that perhaps that was a mistake. We treated the CIA like an American institution that believes in American values, like freedom of speech, freedom of worship and the freedom to peaceably assemble. At least in America.

However, if displeasure with one story the newspaper publishes causes a government agency to pull all its ads in retribution, then we assume everyone should be afraid of the CIA — and maybe the whole government — because it's obviously "my way or the highway" with them. For us they can pull advertising and satisfy their thirst for revenge.

But what might they do to organizations where such a simple step isn't readily available?

We don't care about the money. God knows we don't publish this newspaper to get rich. We care about the principle.

Do we have free speech here or not?

For anyone who ever doubted that special interests control the media, there could be no better proof.




 

Comments

 

Anonymous

Posted Sep 21 2011

You have the right to free speech...say what you wish.

THEY have the right to advertise where they see fit.

Get over it.

Anonymous

Posted Sep 21 2011


That happened in America ??? Ubelievable !! What went wrong with their democracy principles?!!HA

Anonymous

Posted Sep 22 2011

Unfortunately, your experience with this particular instance may not be unique at all. There is a pervasive attitude in the government that its work and objectives are holy (who knows in accordance to what standards) and it is fair to do anything to accomplish its goals. Do you actually believe that there is no justification for the lives that are lost in the wars, policies and turning the blind eye to atrocities? They full well know about it, justified and rationalized it out for themselves. It just hurts when it hits you yourself directly. If you can't believe these words, then ask yourself, wasn't there a bill of rights (and the constitution) when the government was issuing certificates of ownership for slaves? Welcome to America!

Disclaimer: Comments do not necessarily reflect the views of New America Media. NAM reserves the right to edit or delete comments. Once published, comments are visible to search engines and will remain in their archives. If you do not want your identity connected to comments on this site, please refrain from commenting or use a handle or alias instead of your real name.