Agent Orange Studies Overlook Vietnamese Americans

Agent Orange Studies Overlook Vietnamese Americans

Story tools

Comments

A A AResize

Print

Share and Email

 
Tieng Viet

A few years ago, my father, a former naval officer in the South Vietnamese Army, developed liver cancer. The diagnosis followed decades of struggle with Hepatitis C, a viral infection he contracted through a blood transfusion during the war. A liver transplant saved his life.

More than two years since the operation, and my father’s life has been transformed from a state of “wait and see” to near normalcy, except for a daily regimen of dozens of pills. But, for Vietnamese Americans there is another legacy of the war that, like a sleeping dragon, may be starting to awaken: The possible health effects of exposure to wartime Agent Orange.

American forces sprayed 19 million gallons of Agent Orange and other herbicides during the Vietnam War between 1961 and 1971, mostly in South Vietnam, to deny North Vietnamese soldiers cover in the country’s dense forests and jungles. Agent Orange was contaminated with dioxin, a highly toxic chemical that is persistent in human tissues and the environment.

That wartime spraying has been devastating to American veterans who came into contact with the defoliant and then developed any number of a long list of illnesses related to Agent Orange exposure. The U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs, Institute of Medicine and the National Academy of Sciences have linked Agent Orange/dioxin exposure to a slew of health conditions, including prostate, lung and other cancers, Parkinson’s disease and leukemia, and birth defects in the children of veterans, such as spina bifida. Many of the symptoms are only just showing up now in soldiers who served and were exposed.

But the numerous studies on American veterans of the war stand in stark contrast to what little is known about the health effects of dioxin in Vietnamese living in the United States – whether they were born here or are former residents of South Vietnam.

According to a study published in the journal Nature by Columbia University professor emeritus Jeanne Stellman, as many as 4.8 million Vietnamese civilians were exposed to the chemicals during the war. The collapse of the government of South Vietnam brought an exodus of Vietnamese to the United States, with more than 125,000 refugees resettling here after 1975. The country’s Vietnamese population now stands at more than 1.6 million, according to the last census count.

Among that group are former South Vietnamese veterans, who do not receive VA benefits,  so their health status is not being tracked. The federal government has yet to conduct large-scale epidemiological studies of U.S. Vietnam veterans, and has not funded studies on their South Vietnamese counterparts.

Additionally, ARVN forces were not part of a 1985 out-of-court settlement with the chemical makers totaling $180 million. Much of that money dried up before thousands of American veterans started to become sick from Agent Orange-related illnesses. Now, as the legal and medical battles move to the children and grandchildren of Vietnam vets who are also suffering the long-term effects of the chemical war agent, Vietnamese Americans continue to be overlooked.

Sailing up and down rivers in Binh Duong province in southern Vietnam during the war, my father says he didn’t handle Agent Orange. But he does  recalled seeing charred vegetation along the riverbanks, and said he knew it had been sprayed there. He says he doesn’t believe he was exposed, as he was mainly on the vessel and drank from the boat’s water supply.

But studies show the defoliant was sprayed on about 10 to 15 percent of South Vietnam in certain locations, with little spraying in urban areas. From Saigon, my father says areas outside of the city were sprayed. One in particular, Bien Hoa, just 32 kilometers north of Saigon, is a dioxin “hotspot.”

Bien Hoa is home to a former U.S. air base used for Agent Orange-spraying missions. A large spill of the herbicide occurred underground there, and the area is still contaminated. A study from 2003 found that residents were still exposed to dioxin through animal fat, from eating fish, chickens and ducks and other tainted wildlife.

Bien Hoa residents also had higher dioxin levels than their counterparts in the North, where there was no spraying, and one resident of the city was found to have the highest level of dioxin ever recorded in the country. But while their children also showed elevated dioxin levels, these studies did not address long-term health effects.

Arnold Schecter, a professor of environmental sciences at the Univ. of Texas School of Public Health in Dallas and a leading researcher on dioxin exposure in the Vietnamese American community, said no one has conducted measures of dioxin exposure levels in the population.

Political Sensitivities

Vietnamese immigrants in the United States are largely from South Vietnam, which fell to the communists in 1975. As such, many here do not want to do or say anything that gives credence to Hanoi’s claims about the health effects of Agent Orange, part of a massive campaign to win compensation for victims of the defoliant. [A lawsuit brought by Vietnam against the chemical makers in federal court in New York was dismissed in 2005, and subsequent appeals have failed.]

Yet the lack of health studies for this group comes at a time when the symptoms of wartime exposure to Agent Orange/dioxin could be surfacing.

According to a Chicago Tribune investigation, “Service-related disability payments to Vietnam veterans have surged 60 percent since 2003, reaching $13.7 billion last year, and now account for more than half of such payments the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs provides to veterans of all wars.” The spike in disability claims suggests that the “long dormant effects of Agent Orange [are beginning] to surface,” according to the article.

For Vietnamese immigrants in the United States, who may have had a history of toxic exposure, it is critical to have this basic and baseline public health data, especially as many go on to work in jobs here, such as nail salons and dry cleaning shops, where they are exposed to additional harmful chemicals.

Growing up, my siblings and I never knew what my father saw or did on the battlefield, what he felt when he loaded his mother, brothers and sisters, his wife and his nine-month-old daughter, and others onto a ship that he then commandeered to Subic Bay, Philippines on April 30, 1975 – the day Saigon fell. We are just starting to have those conversations.

Now, with both my parents aging, the legacy of the war is both a distant memory and a palpable reality, sometimes extending its fingers into our lives.

Ngoc Nguyen is environmental health editor and reporter for New America Media, a national nonprofit news service for ethnic media. She is reporting on the health impacts of Agent Orange/dioxin on the Vietnamese American community through a grant from the Fund for Investigative Journalism. Contact her at nnguyen@newamericamedia.org.
 

Comments

 
Anonymous

Posted Oct 19 2011

As a Vietnam veteran with a Vietnamese wife and family I am very sorry to say that the U.S. Government and certainly the U.S. Congress is not ever going to provide serious money and medical assistance to those who (can prove they) are afflicted with Agent Orange induced conditions. Nicholas Rock, Seattle, WA

Anonymous

Posted Oct 19 2011

Sorry to read of the terrible problem you and your familiy are facing due to Agent Orange, and hope that at some future date you along with others will other Vietnamese and sufferers will receive support from the US government.

Meanwhile I hope you and others in the US will understand that in Vietnam - on which 80 million litres of Agent Orange was sprayed - the four million Vietnamese has not received a cent in compensation either from the US Government or any of the Us Chemical companies headed by Monsanto.

Anonymous

Posted Oct 24 2011

Neither the U.S. government nor the chemical companies will ever acknowledge the damage their actions have caused. Vietnamese citizens and U.S. military veterans are not the only ones the U.S. government contaminated with dioxin in defoliant sprays. During the 1970s the U.S.D.A. Forest Service sprayed millions of acres of national forest in the Pacific Northwest with the same ingredients comprising Agent Orange (2,4-D and 2,4,5-T), contaminating entire watersheds with dioxin (notably, 2,3,7,8-TCDD), which was found in our water supplies, our soil, our wildlife, including deer and elk meat, as well as in human mothers' milk and tissues from a baby born without a brain. Needless to say, no compensation or medical help has ever been provided to citizens exposed to this poison, nor have any follow-up tests for dioxin or studies of health effects been conducted. In this regard, we are all Vietnamese, utterly disposable to the U.S. government and its corporate sponsors.

Anonymous

Posted Oct 25 2011

i sprayed more than a million gallons of agent orange herbicides on the tiny island of guam over a ten year period starting in 1968. the dioxin levels on guam approach 19,000 PPM in the soil in a recent MONSANTO DOW CHEMICAL RISK REPORT IN 2004/2005. ALSO MY AIR FORCE DOCUMENTS SHOW MY DUTIES OF SPRAYING THESE HERBICIDES AND EYE WITNESSES STILL ALIVE BARELY. I CAN BE REACHED AT RETAIRFORCEMAN@aol.com and also contact NICK DELGADO OF KUAM NEWS SERVICE who is fully aware along with CONGRESSWOMAN MADELINE BORDALLO OF GUAM.

Anonymous

Posted Oct 25 2011

i sprayed more than a million gallons of agent orange herbicides on the tiny island of guam over a ten year period starting in 1968. the dioxin levels on guam approach 19,000 PPM in the soil in a recent MONSANTO DOW CHEMICAL RISK REPORT IN 2004/2005. ALSO MY AIR FORCE DOCUMENTS SHOW MY DUTIES OF SPRAYING THESE HERBICIDES AND EYE WITNESSES STILL ALIVE BARELY. I CAN BE REACHED AT RETAIRFORCEMAN@aol.com and also contact NICK DELGADO OF KUAM NEWS SERVICE who is fully aware along with CONGRESSWOMAN MADELINE BORDALLO OF GUAM. THOUSANDS OF CHILDREN AND CIVILIAN WORKERS WERE DIRECTLY EXPOSED TO THOSE HERBICIDES THAT I SPRAYED THERE AS THEY WATCHED ME GO BY OR THEY WERE SPRAYING WITH SMALL BACK PACK SPRAYERS.

Anonymous

Posted Nov 18 2011

After 40 years the VA finally provides me with disability care due to Agent Orange related heart damage and diabetes. However, nine months after my return from Vietnam my wife had our first and only child. The little girl with born with a severe birth defect. Thirty plus years later my little girl had a child of her own who was born severely autistic. They receive no care or compensation and likely never will. interestingly, the VA requests they be 'added to a data base' for purely study purposes.

People like the kids of Vets, South Vietnamese civilians and former military as well as NVA and VC will never see 'compensation'. Such are the fortunes of war. The sins of the Fathers are visited upon their children. (except for most of the children of the politicians and contractors who skipped out on the war).

Disclaimer: Comments do not necessarily reflect the views of New America Media. NAM reserves the right to edit or delete comments. Once published, comments are visible to search engines and will remain in their archives. If you do not want your identity connected to comments on this site, please refrain from commenting or use a handle or alias instead of your real name.